Greatest Maple Leafs: No. 16 Red Kelly

An all-star with the Detroit Red Wings, Red Kelly had his best times in Toronto. Photo: Graphic Artists/HHOF Images

Each day from now until the Winter Classic, Sportsnet will count down the greatest Toronto Maple Leafs of all time.

Step inside Red Kelly’s north Toronto home and it’s impossible not to notice the awards lining the mahogany walls and adorning the mantels of seemingly every room—it’s like a museum dedicated to one of hockey’s most celebrated figures. There are the silver plates and serving trays from his eight Stanley Cups (they didn’t give out rings in Kelly’s day) and the plaques honouring his Norris Trophy, four Lady Byng Trophies and 1969 Hall of Fame induction. In the corner of his office, behind a desk that looks out onto his sprawling backyard, is a plaque issued by Encyclopedia Britannica that reads “Achievement in Life.” Hanging above an overstuffed couch with a Maple Leafs throw pillow on it is a giant frame with “Red Kelly Day Proclamation in Canada, April 4, 1989” in it. Beside it hangs a signed letter from the Queen dating back to the years he spent representing his Toronto riding of York-West in Parliament while still a Leaf—mementos from a lifetime in hockey in a time when it mattered most.

A true-blue Leafs fan growing up near Port Dover, Ont., Kelly will never forget meeting his heroes, Charlie Conacher and Red Horner, at the Simcoe County fair. “I came home and told my family, ‘You’ll never guess who shook this hand…'” he recalls, leaning forward in his chair, his arm outstretched. “I didn’t wash it for a week.”

As a teenager, he moved to Toronto to play for St. Mike’s, then in its heyday as a pro hockey factory, where he began to show the skills that would set him apart in the NHL: excellent passing ability, great vision and a unique ability to manoeuvre the puck with his skates. At 19, the Detroit Red Wings had seen enough to sign him. “If I could have picked any team to play on I would have chosen Toronto,” he says, “but I was tickled pink that anybody would want me.”

Over more than 12 seasons—and four Stanley Cups—in Detroit, Kelly established himself as one of the NHL’s most skilled and versatile players. But his lifelong dream of playing for the Blue and White almost didn’t happen. After a dispute with Red Wings GM Jack Adams over a proposed trade to the Rangers, Kelly abruptly retired late in the 1959–60 season. He had been away from hockey all of one week before his wife, Andra, got a phone call from Conn Smythe asking if Red would consider becoming a Maple Leaf. Kelly flew to Toronto and met with the Leafs GM and coach Punch Imlach, who told him, “If we’re going to win the Stanley Cup we’re going have to go through Montreal, and I need someone to check Jean Béliveau. I’m thinking about starting you at centre against him. Whaddya think?”

Kelly signed his contract at midnight and suited up against Béliveau and the Canadiens that night. “Walking up to Maple Leaf Gardens that night I have never—even in a Stanley Cup playoff—felt what I felt,” Mrs. Kelly recalls, pouring her husband a cup of tea. “You could really see how excited Red was to come home.”

Kelly took the ice for the opening face-off to a standing room—only crowd chanting his name. “There was such a roar,” he says, “that the hair on the back of my neck stood straight up, like a violin string pulled as tight as you can get it. My life was back in hockey.”

He remembers that first shift vividly—how he won the faceoff, fired the puck to the left of Jacques Plante and rocketed towards the Habs’ goalie. “I would’ve gone right through him, but he just dropped to the ice to cover the puck and I went ass over tea kettle over top of him and landed on my head.”

It got better from there. In Kelly’s eight seasons in Toronto, the Maple Leafs reached eight semis and claimed four Cups. “We had a great thing going here,” Kelly says, looking at the two massive rings he recently received, each representing four championships. A huge grin emerges on his 85-year-old face. “That’s eight Stanley Cups that Montreal didn’t win.” Spoken like a true Leaf.

When submitting content, please abide by our submission guidelines, and avoid posting profanity, personal attacks or harassment. Should you violate our submissions guidelines, we reserve the right to remove your comments and block your account. Sportsnet reserves the right to close a story’s comment section at any time.