Instant Analysis: Leafs re-sign Komarov

After a season in the KHL, the Maple Leafs have brought back agitator Leo Komarov on a four-year, $11.8 million contract.

The Signing: Leo Komarov, C, 27, with the Toronto Maple Leafs

The Deal: Four years, $11.8 million

The Cap Hit: $2.95 million

Where he fits: At the money the Leafs signed him for, you’d say he fits as a third-liner. Based on history and past performance, however, you’d have to say he’s a fourth-liner.

The Good: The greatest proof of Komarov’s worth was what happened in his absence. With Komarov, the 2012–13 Maple Leafs gave opponents fits in the lockout-shortened season. Without him last winter, Toronto was anything but hard to play against. His supporting role in the Leafs’ over-achieving run to the playoffs was easy to miss, but it was a point driven home by his nasty and effective play in Finland’s run to Olympic bronze in Sochi. The Leafs are now a marginally tougher team to play than they were most of last season.

The Bad: Komarov would be a great signing for a team that was close to contending—a good last piece. The Leafs have fundamental needs that should be a priority and wrapping up $3 million in a role player probably will come back to haunt them next summer when entering the UFA market and trying to re-sign RFAs.

The Grade: C-. Leafs fans shrugged off Komarov’s jumping to the KHL last off-season, but he was again top of mind during the Olympics. On a day when the Leafs have to watch Dave Bolland head off to Florida, Komarov’s signing is a ribbon for participation.

Sportsnet.ca no longer supports comments.