HOUSTON – Sitting in the visitors' dugout at Daikin Park Monday afternoon, Jeff Hoffman searched for the right word to describe his emotions.
“Sad,” he said. “You spend so much time with these guys that everybody gets really close. Obviously with what we did last year, everybody's even closer. So it’s kind of tough to say goodbye.”
Minutes later, Daulton Varsho tried to make sense of his day in the nearby press conference room. Wearing a short-sleeved blue and orange Astros hoodie, Varsho revealed that he broke down and cried with Kevin Gausman and George Springer on the flight from Toronto to Houston.
By the time Varsho spoke, Gausman was already making his way to Chicago to join the Cubs. Meanwhile, Shane Bieber was preparing for a start in Houston – but the Blue Jays also had to have a contingency plan just in case he was traded, too.
All of which to say, the 2026 trade deadline was a busy and emotionally draining one for the Blue Jays.
"For me myself, the biggest emotion is letting down our fans and letting down the clubhouse,” GM Ross Atkins said after dealing away three big parts of the 2025 American League championship team, along with left-hander Adam Macko and three prospects including Arjun Nimmala.
Of course, the Blue Jays got a lot in return, too. Jose Soriano is the headliner, but Spencer Arrighetti and Jameson Taillon will also join the MLB rotation, utility player Josh Smith brings versatility, and they acquired six prospects.
“It's been busy,” said manager John Schneider. “It’s been exciting. It's been emotional … but when you look up, you like what you got in return and we still really like our team.”
After all that, a strong outing by Shane Bieber and a home run from Alejandro Kirk led the Blue Jays to a 3-1 win over the Astros in their series opener. Here’s a closer look at what stands out from the 2026 trade deadline:
A CLICHE BECOMES REALITY
Every summer, some teams talk about how they could buy and sell at once. Easy to say, but tough to do. This year, the Blue Jays pulled it off, trading away three established big-leaguers in Gausman, Varsho and Hoffman while simultaneously buying one of the top pitchers available in Soriano.
In contrast to 2024, when they traded nine players off their big-league roster, the core of their roster remains together this time. So while they did sell this week, this was far more modest in scale. And while the addition of Soriano will help them immediately, he’s also under team control for two seasons after this one, and that’s seemingly the driving force behind the move.
It’s a first for the Blue Jays under Atkins, whose previous 10 trade deadlines could easily be bucketed into ‘buy’ or ‘sell.’ Now it’s time for a third hybrid category.
MORE VETERAN PRESENCE
The Blue Jays considered dealing the likes of Bieber, Springer and others but ultimately decided that they were more valuable than whatever trade return they would have brought back.
Asked about Springer, Atkins said: “We wanted him here.”
Both are free agents after the season, and Bieber’s a potential fit in Toronto while it’s unclear what Springer’s plans are after 2026 and whether he intends to continue playing.
The same applies to Gausman, who’s well within his rights to talk with the Blue Jays again after the season if he decides he wants to keep playing in 2027. It wouldn’t be the first time a veteran pitcher has returned to a team that traded him, as Merrill Kelly of the Diamondbacks can attest.
ARMS FIRST BATS LATER
Not only was the Blue Jays’ star acquisition a pitcher, but they also acquired more total pitchers (six) than hitters (four).
With a 97 m.p.h. fastball and the ability to generate ground balls in bunches, Soriano has front-of-the-rotation upside. Prospect Dasan Hill, one of three players to come back in the Hoffman trade, is a former second-rounder with big stuff and a high-risk, high-reward profile. Arrighetti has options, an above-average 24.6 per cent strikeout rate and some upside if the Blue Jays want to get creative with his role.
These are pitchers any team would want in their organization. Sometimes it’s best to take the best talent available and figure out the depth chart later. At the same time, it doesn’t change the fact that the Blue Jays are 30th among the 30 MLB teams in runs scored.
That means two things: one, these last couple months are essential for finding some offensive answers internally. And two, adding offence will likely be high on the team’s off-season to-do list.
MOVING FORWARD
If the Blue Jays were hybrid buyers and sellers with a 52-60 record and 5.0 per cent playoff odds, how aggressive would they have been at, say, 60-52? We’ll never know, but they dealt away Nimmala in the Soriano deal, so it’s not as though they were opposed to trading away young talent. And their history certainly suggests they would have been aggressive on relievers and bench bats if they had a winning record.
Ultimately, the Blue Jays just didn’t win enough games to justify buying further for 2026, and the likes of Gausman, Varsho and Hoffman all expressed disappointment about that underperformance as they left for new teams.
For the rest of the Blue Jays, this deadline positions them better for 2027 and beyond without ruling anything out for the current season.
4:08
