Should the Maple Leafs pull the trigger on a Vladislav Gavrikov trade?

Philadelphia Flyers' Cam Atkinson, right, shoots the puck as Columbus Blue Jackets' Vladislav Gavrikov defends during the first period of an NHL hockey game Thursday, April 7, 2022, in Columbus, Ohio. (Jay LaPrete/AP)

An element from the 2022 edition of the Toronto Maple Leafs’ top four has been stripped and not replaced — yet.

Rugged Ilya Lyubushkin walked away in free agency, and tough, savvy veteran Jake Muzzin has seen his career placed in jeopardy due to an early-season spine injury.

Mind you, to the blue line’s credit, those absences have been filled by committee. Emerging defenders Timothy Liljegren and Rasmus Sandin have expanded their minutes, matured in their roles, and risen to tougher competition.

A Morgan Rielly knee ailment and multiple injuries to top-four mainstay T.J. Brodie gave the newfound depth — Conor Timmins, Jordie Benn, Victor Mete, Mac Hollowell — intermittent windows to flex their worth.

As far as the regular season is concerned, Toronto’s defence has been just fine, thank you.

So, when Leaf Nation learns that GM Kyle Dubas has inquired on Columbus Blue Jackets defender Vladislav Gavrikov, as Elliotte Friedman and Jeff Marek reported Saturday, a segment of the fan base balks.

Do the Maple Leafs — ranked fifth leaguewide in goals against — even need another D-man?

If so, is Gavrikov worth the price, considering other contenders – Edmonton among them – are also interested in his services?

The 27-year-old Russian is an impending unrestricted free agent with a cap hit so manageable ($2.8 million) that, provided Muzzin remains on LTIR and Columbus retains some money, the Leafs may be able to acquire forward help as well.

(Dubas has struck multi-player deadline deals in the past, with Los Angeles and Seattle, so a combo pitch for, say, Gavrikov and winger Gustav Nyquist, for example, might make sense.)

For now, at least, Gavrikov will not come cheap to Toronto or Edmonton or wherever he lands.

Jackets GM Jarmo Kekalainen is hoping for a return package similar to the one he received in 2021 for renting stay-at-home defenceman David Savard (with 50 per cent salary retention) to Tampa Bay (a first-round pick, a third-round pick) or what Montreal received for renting Ben Chiarot (again, with retention) to Florida at the 2022 deadline (a first-round pick, a fourth-round pick, plus prospect Ty Smilanic).

Gavrikov isn’t going to intimidate as fiercely or hit as frequently as a Chiarot. He’s not quite as battle-hardened or experienced as Savard.

But what the left-shot, middle-pairing D-man will do is eat up a bunch of unglamorous minutes — penalty kill, D-zone draws, top-six shutdown assignments — stuff out cycles and box out in front of the net.

He’s safe and reliable and, with offensive contributions minimal (three goals, seven assists this season), won’t exactly bump William Nylander and Mitch Marner out of the Leafs highlight pack.

More importantly, Gavrikov would relieve some of the workload currently weighing on the oldest skater in the NHL, Mark Giordano, and allow coach Sheldon Keefe to pair Brodie with Rielly.

Gavrikov’s hits (49, roughly one per game) are down from last season’s career high of 124, but he’s logging significant minutes (22:16), is more than willing to block shots (80), and — for the first time in his career — has more takeaways (17) than giveaways (12).

He’s a safe puck manager, which helps explain why, despite starting 70.4 per cent of his shifts in the D-zone, mostly against quality forwards, he’s only a minus-5 on a disastrous club with a minus-62 goal differential.

Dubas knows firsthand the impact Gavrikov’s meat-and-potatoes game can have on a series, as he was instrumental in frustrating Toronto’s forwards during the Leafs’ 2020 bubble series loss to Columbus.

Gavrikov’s agent, Dan Milstein, has the green light to talk extension with potential acquiring teams, and the player himself appears to have wrapped his head around a change of address.

It’s believed he’ll be asking for an AAV in the ballpark of $5 million on a long-term deal, and Kekalainen hasn’t been willing to go there just yet. Which is why a loyal, career-long Blue Jacket finds himself on the block.

“That’s part of the game, right?” Gavrikov told the Columbus Dispatch when asked about a possible midseason trade.

“It’s part of the business, so I’m ready for anything. You’ve got to stay a pro, right? And you’ve got to take what’s in front of you.

“I have to not think about it so much. I’m just focused on my game and the team, so that’s it. There’s nothing I can change right now.”

Gavrikov is a proven stay-at-home minute-muncher in a league hungry for more of his ilk. Coaches, teammates, and fans in Columbus all sing his praises.

Absolutely, we like the player’s fit in Toronto, where a deep run through Tampa and Boston will require depth.

That said, Edmonton may be more aggressive in the left-shot defender market.

And the last time Dubas traded a first-round pick to Columbus for a rental piece (Nick Foligno, 2021), the price rang too high in retrospect.

Our bet: Unless the asking price for Gavrikov dips, Dubas gets outbid here.

When submitting content, please abide by our submission guidelines, and avoid posting profanity, personal attacks or harassment. Should you violate our submissions guidelines, we reserve the right to remove your comments and block your account. Sportsnet reserves the right to close a story’s comment section at any time.