John Herdman reflects on challenges of 1st year in charge of Canadian men’s team


Canadian coach John Herdman. (Mark Blinch/CP)

John Herdman is anxious.

The Canadian men’s team hosts French Guiana in Vancouver on Sunday, and the Reds can clinch a spot in the “A League” of the inaugural Concacaf Nations League tournament with a win or a draw.

But that’s not why Herdman is anxious. He’s anxious just to take charge of his team again. Anxious to play a competitive match again. Anxious just to get out on the field again. Sunday’s game will be Canada’s first since November, when it earned a 1-0 road win over Saint Kitts and Nevis in a Nations League qualifier.

“I’m really excited to get going. It’s weird. It’s weird not being on the pitch for five months. It’s unreal,” Herdman admitted.

Sunday’s affair comes exactly one year after Herdman’s first game in charge of Canada, a 1-0 victory over New Zealand in a friendly in San Pedro del Pinatar, Spain.

On the eve of his one-year anniversary of his debut as Canadian coach, Herdman chatted one-on-one with Sportsnet on a variety of topics, including the progress the team has made in the last 12 months, qualifying for the 2022 World Cup, co-hosting the 2026 World Cup, how he intends to use teen phenom Alphonso Davies, and much more.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Sportsnet: How has the last year gone by for you since that win over New Zealand in Spain?

Herdman: It was a slow start, what with having to make an evaluation of everything, talking to all the players and evaluating things in terms of how we change the culture surrounding the team. We had to work very hard and do a lot of restructuring internally and in terms of staffing, and develop a clarity about how we were going to go about changing the way we do things, from top to bottom, from the senior side down to the youth teams. Everything from new sports science staff, new medical staff, new performance coaches.

People only see what happens on the pitch, whether it was last March versus New Zealand or in the Nations League qualifiers, but there’s been a genuine rebuild in a short period of time to create a strategy, and then to put a structure around that strategy, not just for the men’s team but also influencing the Canadian soccer system. That meant getting out to the provinces, and talking to local coaches, talking to the MLS clubs and working alongside them to build relationships. It’s been a good year, but it’s been hard as there’s been a lot of work to do to move the program forward.

What kind of progress has the team made in 12 months? Is the team where you thought it would be at this point?

The recruitment of players like Ballou Tabla and others who could have played for other countries, there’s been some real wins there that will set us up for the future. To get senior players and players from overseas, guys who have often been in and out of training camps, and made choices as to when they would represent Canada, they’ve been re-motivated. The youth movement, as well, we’ve been able to integrate a lot of youngsters and teenagers into the system. That’s important for us on a number of levels, like knowing where the team will be in four years. There’s been good elements around player commitment, player strategies and player recruitment.

On the pitch, it’s been a little challenging. The challenging part has been understanding that you’re working in very tight and short windows of time against opponents that are difficult to scout, so I would say we’re not quite where I want the team to be at this stage. We’ve had games against New Zealand, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Dominica and the U.S. Virgin Islands – these are tier-two opponents. Also, I think our identity on the pitch has been loose in games. The tactical excellence that we’ve been pushing for on the field has been loose, so there’s still a lot of work to be done. The team spirit is bubbling away nicely, and that’s starting to create a culture where people can challenge each other and ask these hard questions about their accountability on the field.

What have been the biggest challenges of your tenure thus far?

I think there was this scepticism to break down because this is a program that hasn’t won anything since the [2000] Gold Cup. I was surprised by how many relationships were really fragile, and with that the amount of time you have to spend to repair them. Just in terms of integration with the MLS clubs, it was hard to break down the initial barriers because they hadn’t had that communication at this level, so there was this scepticism from them of “Why? Why do you want to work with us now when you didn’t want to before?” It was more realizing that this is going to take a lot of work to improve relationships and prove ourselves in every communication we make. We have to operate at the highest level of professionalism and delivery, because if we don’t then people aren’t going to listen. So, it’s been about galvanizing this country around [the 2026 World Cup] and giving all the stakeholders a sense that we can work together to make and create better opportunities for Canadian players.

You mentioned changing the culture of the team. How hard was that and is that still a work in progress?

I think culture is always a work in progress because it’s built on trust, and it’s built on doing what you say you’re going to do and doing it consistently. The minute that consistency drops and you’re not doing the things you said you were going to do, you lose trust and the culture you’re working for quickly disappears. We’re trying to set standards because we want people to feel that we have clear vision for the country that we can all attach ourselves to.

So, it’s been a cultural shift at every level. We’ve recognized that if we just work in a silo with the team, we only reach a certain amount of stakeholders and people who can help the program to the next level. That’s why we felt it was so important to go into every province and talk to coaches, provincial officials, technical directors of clubs about our vision and the strategies we have in place. All of this is about the cultural shift, and if we can get this in place, for me, that’s the biggest part of the legacy we leave – we can leave the program better than we found it if those bonds between provinces and clubs and the national team are improved. If we do that, I feel we can compete consistently with the top national teams in Concacaf.

You genuinely feel Canada can compete with the top Concacaf nations?

Yes, I do. I keep saying this. My staff have done extensive research and looked back at past teams, and everything suggests we have the talent in this country, and always had the talent in relation to our Concacaf competitors. But we’ve been very fragmented on all levels, and it’s almost as though people want to see us fail. As an example, you go into our Nations League qualifier versus Dominica in Toronto [last year], and local clubs [in Ontario] are playing friendlies against Dominica to help them prepare for Canada! In no other country in the world would that be allowed or would that happen, but it happened in Canada. Why? In many ways, that’s football treason. So, you get a sense we have work to do and it’s still fragile to convince people and get them onboard.

Last month, you boldly proclaimed that Canada would qualify for the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar, and would be competitive in the 2026 World Cup that Canada will co-host with Mexico and the United States. I’m not sure many of your predecessors would have done that. Why did you make that proclamation?

I think with some who came before me, it was more about saving their jobs or looking after their role within the team. That’s what I’ve learned about the men’s game at the international level. It’s such a frail role that coaches are in that no one ever wants to set themselves up to fail.

This group of players believes it’s possible, and if their coach does not support their vision, then nothing is real in your environment. So, it’s always been a case of let’s under-promise and over-deliver. At the end of the day, when you look to under-promise, you tend to under-deliver. It’s all about where your sights are set.

This group of men have a responsibility, my staff has a responsibility, and there’s a group of people in powerful positions in this country who have a responsibility to take this team to 2022 and get it ready for 2026. And that’s as an entire organization. That’s not John Herdman saying we’re going to qualify. That’s me putting everybody on guard – from the Canada Soccer board, to our president, to our general secretary, the provincial bodies. It’s everybody. It’s time, and we’re not going to get this time back, so we have to use it wisely. We have the talent to qualify, so let’s do everything we can to do it.

What do you see as Alphonso Davies’ role with the national team going forward?

In games where we expected teams to defend deep, knowing there wouldn’t be much space in behind, we wanted him coming from deep and arriving onto things and on switches of play, rather than be the focal point for defences; having him in a chameleon-like role where he would appear in time and spaces where defenders we already preoccupied with other players. We’ve looked at him in deeper roles, like a fullback or wingback, but I think in the future in tougher matches, he’ll be deployed as a forward, and that’s his best position. You’ll see him higher up the field, giving us opportunities in transition.


When submitting content, please abide by our submission guidelines, and avoid posting profanity, personal attacks or harassment. Should you violate our submissions guidelines, we reserve the right to remove your comments and block your account. Sportsnet reserves the right to close a story’s comment section at any time.