For the Toronto Blue Jays, this off-season’s top two priorities are clear: offence and starting pitching. Yet a close third should be finding a left-handed leverage reliever. Here’s why.
Last season, 48.8 per cent of plate appearances league-wide were hit left-handed — the highest amount since the league expanded from 16 to 18 teams in 1961. Of the 135 players who qualified for the batting title, 77 hit left-handed or from both sides. That’s the most since 2009 and only the seventh time there has ever been 75 or more.
It wasn’t an aberration — MLB hitters have been trending more left-handed for years. It wouldn’t be a surprise to see 2027 mark the first season all-time with a majority of plate appearances taken from the left side. And the quality of all the left-handed hitters in today’s game is exceptional. Order last season’s qualified batters by wRC+ and you’ll find 18 of the top 30 are left-handed or switch-hitters. And 10 of the top 15.
With Louis Varland, Tyler Rogers, Spencer Miles, and Braydon Fisher, the Blue Jays have adequate right-handed pitching capable of facing leverage. But from the other side last season, Mason Fluharty’s MLB-high 83 appearances nearly tripled that of Toronto’s next most-used lefty, Brendon Little, who pitched in 30 games.
Joe Mantiply, currently a free agent, made 25 appearances. Adam Macko, currently a Texas Ranger, made 22. Rookies Brandan Cellucci (six appearances) and Ricky Tiedemann (five) round out the list. And undrafted soon-to-be 25-year-old Javen Coleman, whose 2026 ended on the IL after he reached triple-A in late July, is the only left-handed reliever in the Blue Jays minor-league system knocking on the big-league door. It’s a big gap on Toronto’s depth chart.
Among free agents, 27-year-old fireballer Adrian Morejon is unquestionably the top left-handed reliever available. But you’ll have to outbid several of MLB’s top spenders and surrender draft pick compensation to sign him to a multi-year deal that could near nine figures. That’s a lot of risk to accept for an absurdly hard thrower who wasn’t available to his club for last month’s divisional series due to a shoulder issue.
Barring a big splash for Morejon, the Blue Jays will need to cast a wider net to address this need. Here are four other free agent lefties with leverage upside the club could consider.
Alex Vesia
When acquiring pitchers, the Blue Jays are always on the hunt for unique fastballs with characteristics that distinguish them from the league-average offerings hitters see on a nightly basis. One of those differentiators is induced vertical break (IVB): how much a fastball’s backspin fights gravity to create a perceived rising effect — in actuality, the pitch isn’t dropping as much as expected — in the eyes of hitters.
Trey Yesavage (19.4 inches of IVB on average in 2026) and Dylan Cease (18.5) are great examples, combining backspin and velocity to sneak their heaters above bats at the top of the zone. But no pitcher in baseball throws a fastball with as much IVB — a whopping 21.2 inches on average — as Vesia, whose 92 m.p.h. fastball has produced the same run value on a per-pitch basis over the last two seasons as Paul Skenes and Jacob Misiorowski.
That’s what happens when you work with exceptional ride from an extreme over-the-top delivery — no MLB pitcher throws from a higher arm angle — at the height of the zone. Hitters consistently hit weak pop-ups and flyballs, or whiff underneath pitches entirely, because they’re so unaccustomed to seeing fastballs with life like Vesia’s.
It’s an illusion that makes the 30-year-old resilient to velocity decline, which he’s been experiencing since 2024. He’s lost over two ticks off his fastball in that time yet still pitched to a 169 ERA+ over 207 appearances, striking out a third of the hitters he’s faced. And he’s punished lefties, who have hit .146 against Vesia over that span — second-lowest among all MLB pitchers to the incomparable Misiorowski.
Last winter, the Blue Jays signed an unorthodox soft-tosser to a surprisingly lucrative, three-year, $37-million deal, then sat back and watched Tyler Rogers earn every penny and then some. Vesia, who’s been on the injured list only once in his career (a minimum, 15-day stint for a mild oblique strain in 2025), could provide similar, late-game value in an unconventional package from the left side. And it likely won’t cost as much as Rogers did to acquire it.
You can think of Newcomb as a utility reliever. Whether it’s facing a tough pocket in leverage, throwing multiple innings as a bridge following a shorter start, opening against the top of the order, or entering with runners on to bail a teammate out of a tough spot, the 33-year-old does it all. And his performance against right-handed hitting hasn’t been meaningfully different than when he has the platoon advantage.
That last bit is part of why Atlanta first brought him to the majors as a starter. But since shifting to the bullpen permanently in 2021, Newcomb’s stuff has ticked up. He’ll now sit in the mid-90s, regularly touching 97. And over the last two years he’s finally worked out the right mix of his multiple fastball (four-seamer, sinker, cutter) and breaking ball (slurve, curveball) shapes, producing 3.5 fWAR with a 146 ERA+ over 182.2 IP.
With a deep arsenal, a willingness to make adjustments (Newcomb’s dropped his arm angle from 49 to 26 degrees since 2020, adding multiple pitches along the way), and oodles of arm talent (he can split the plate with a sinker that gets well above-average run and a slurve that cuts more horizontally than any in baseball), there’s reason for developmentally-minded organizations to believe they can unlock even more.
As pitching staffs grow increasingly fluid, versatile arms like Newcomb’s become even more valuable. And the Chicago White Sox demonstrated just how much this October, when Newcomb started a game, followed an opener with runners on, protected a lead in middle innings, and threw multiple frames late, ultimately finishing with a 2.57 ERA across seven innings in four appearances. That’s a weapon that helps any pitching staff.
Since signing a minor-league deal with Houston coming off a nightmare 2024 marred by the unexpected passing of his father, Okert’s been as reliable as any left-handed reliever in the league, pitching to a 159 ERA+ over 139.1 IP while producing 2.8 fWAR. His 22.3 per cent K-BB ranks top-10 among all qualified lefty relievers in that span and his 0.86 WHIP is second to only the closer he was setting up for, Josh Hader.
Producing these kinds of results in leverage would typically guarantee a multi-year pact like the ones similar set-up lefties Aaron Bummer, Tim Hill, Brooks Raley, and AJ Minter signed two winters ago. But Okert’s entering his age-35 season and averages only 91 m.p.h. on his fastball, relying instead on control and command of a low-80s slider he throws two-thirds of the time to move off barrels and induce weak flyball contact. It’s a riskier profile to bet on than that of a hard thrower with a dominant fastball.
But Okert’s platoon-neutral slider has been so good — it’s amassed a +25 run value since 2025, trailing only Chris Sale and Mason Miller’s sliders — that he can get away with his fastball at the letters against hitters geared up for something spinning down in the zone.
That’s how he’s stayed above bats and mitigated the home run issues many extreme flyball pitchers like him experience. In front of a big-league defence, a pop-up’s as good as a strikeout. And among the 211 MLB pitchers to throw at least 130 innings since 2025, none has a higher infield fly-ball rate than Okert.
Okert’s 2024 demonstrates the risk of his profile if he loses feel for control and command. And his fastball that season was two ticks harder than the one he threw in 2026. But if he can keep this going for another year, Okert could be a bargain on a one-year, $5 million deal.
AJ Minter
Minter entered his 30s as one of the most dependable left-handed set-up men in the sport, pitching to a 131 ERA+ with a 29.3 K percentage over his first eight big-league seasons with the Atlanta Braves.
Despite his 2024 walk year being interrupted by hip surgery, that solid base of production earned Minter a two-year, $22-million deal from the New York Mets in his first test of free agency. But disaster soon struck when Minter tore his left latissimus dorsi in late April, sending him back to the operating table and ending his 2025.
Following a long, difficult rehab, Minter finally returned in May, finishing the season with a 2.56 ERA over 48 appearances split between the Mets and Minnesota Twins, who acquired him at the trade deadline. The results were there, but Minter’s velocity wasn’t, as he averaged 93.5 m.p.h. on his fastball, down a couple ticks from where it was during his best years with Atlanta.
That decline necessitated a change in approach, which saw Minter lean more heavily on his cutter than ever before, throwing it 55 per cent of the time. The pitch was undeniably effective, as opponents hit .208 against it with a 26.2 per cent whiff rate. But its 106 Stuff+ was a career low, as was the 104 on Minter’s fastball and 91 on the changeup he uses against righties. In his final years with Atlanta, Minter’s Stuff+ measures were consistently above 110 across the board.
That ought to give any team pause when considering Minter for a leverage role. But it should also drive down his price, creating an interesting buy-low opportunity.
Minter’s only 33 and the decline in his velocity and stuff last season can potentially be attributed to coming off multiple major surgeries and needing to rework his pitch mix on the fly. He has a long track record of late-game success in both the regular and post-season, and if a team is confident it can help Minter regain his lost velocity and improve his stuff metrics coming off his first normal off-season in years, it could be a low-cost flier on a proven left-handed setup man rediscovering his form.





1:49