TORONTO — Heading into the 2026-27 NHL season, the new-look Toronto Maple Leafs had a laundry list of questions to answer, but the first and biggest was “Can Auston Matthews be Auston Matthews again?” And, oh buddy, has he ever been Auston Matthews again.
Playing with two guys who I don’t think the league views as elite top-line talents heading into the season in Jack Roslovic and Easton Cowan, he’s seventh in league scoring with elite defending, and his best displays of leadership in his career. He’s been hard on pucks and a better distributor. He’s been excellent.
So, with the headline item on the list of questions getting a big, fat checkmark, what could possibly go wrong with the team?
With the way people are talking about the Leafs today – with some declaring their playoff hopes are dead in the middle of November – it’s probably a good time to evaluate the rest of the pre-season checklist to get those answers.
And let’s be fair about the exercise. What were the actual questions most felt had to be answered for them to have success this season? We’re going to answer those ones.

Real Kyper and Bourne
Nick Kypreos and Justin Bourne talk all things hockey with some of the biggest names in the game. Watch live every weekday on Sportsnet and Sportsnet+ — or listen live on Sportsnet 590 The FAN — from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. ET.
Full episode
Can Auston Matthews be Auston Matthews again? ✅
See above.
Can the D corps hold out? ❌
This was a clear question, and is a massive problem. A lot of the plan on D was “hope these older guys have one more good year left in them,” and they’re maybe one-for-four there, generously.
❌ Jake McCabe: The Leafs have wrung every last drop out of one of their best pros and committed defenders for years now. Only Morgan Rielly has played more on the back end for them since 2023-24, only the minutes haven’t been the same. McCabe has blocked shots and hit and fought and been buried in the D-zone against the best players. It could be for those very reasons that he looks so used up (previous injuries pile up too, of course).
❌ Chris Tanev: You could cut him some slack as he’s coming back from a calendar year of brutal injuries where he’s missed so much time – and we should. Regardless, he doesn’t yet look like himself, even with little things like handling the puck. Maybe he’ll get more comfortable, but he’s also been a step slower, and doesn’t look as able to handle tough competition.
❌ Oliver Ekman-Larsson: Led the Leafs D in scoring last season with 39 points, he’s got one through 23 games this season (an assist). From what we’ve seen so far, he’s like a totally different player now with no offence left to give.
Morgan Rielly: He’s been better than what had become low expectations, but that hasn’t been enough to save a slow, offensively-limited D-corps.
The four players above have combined for 77 games played and zero goals this season.
Can Sergei Bobrovsky still be an effective starter? ❌
A resounding no.
Sportlogiq has his season as the third-worst among goalies who’ve played 10 games (by goals saved above expected per 60) and, going across various sites for data, it seems like you can say that he basically donates one goal per game to the opposition.
He wasn’t good last season and we noted that he was a huge risk on our show when he was tied to the team in the summer. He’s got an Age 35-plus contract that’s, essentially, immovable and un-buyout-able. Him being not just “not good,” but “outright crippling” is devastating after moving off Joseph Woll and Dennis Hildeby, who are cheaper, and about league average this season.
Can John Tavares still play second line centre? ❌
He shot one in the net against Chicago, which was good to see, but his skating has gotten to the point where he just can’t be effective at five-on-five. During the Leafs’ six-game homestand, Tavares played in five of those games, but went pointless.
The top line has been very good and the fourth line has actually been a bright spot, too but their second line hasn’t only been ineffective, it’s been getting lit up.
I didn’t have William Nylander as a pre-season question mark – I didn’t think he was one – but he’s struggled as well – which could be related, though not solely because of, a struggling centreman.
Can Jim Hiller do a better job than Craig Berube? ❌
He doesn’t seem to be coaching with confidence, he’s passed on challenging a couple debatable goals against where his goalie took contact, he’d rather not play the risky but dangerous Gavin McKenna even when chasing games, and, most frustrating, he’s passed on pulling Bobrovsky in games where it could’ve made the difference.
Seven times this season the Leafs have been down a goal in the third period, and then given up a back-breaking goal against, killing the push. Bobrovsky has been in the net for six of those seven, and on a few occasions, there was cause to have him out of the game sooner (as with the Chicago game, where Bedard shot one past him to make it 3-2 to end the second period). A pull for Stolarz and maybe Toronto gets that next save, maybe it finds a point or two.
And that stat doesn’t even count the Seattle game, where the Leafs got it tied late only to give up one more in the dying seconds.
As many people have said, Hiller has thus far failed to give the Leafs an identity – not defensive, offensive, physical or able to play fast – and so he’s got his hands full to get this ship righted.
Can the off-season skater adds provide a better depth look? ❌
Roslovic and Darren Raddysh have been integral adds to the Leafs so far this season. Past them, however, Colton Sissons wasn’t moving the needle before injury, Nick Paul hasn’t offered a lick of offence and Teddy Blueger has just been vanilla.
None of them provide a spark or make plays. Now, Brandon Duhaime and (the great) Zack MacEwen have breathed life into a useful fourth line for the Leafs, so that’s nice. But the money invested in the middle six, which can’t score, looks rough at this point.
As well, outside Raddysh, the Leafs added nothing else of note on defence, and stripped away Brandon Carlo.
Can Kirill Marchenko move the needle? ❌✅
The Leafs are 7-4-2 when Marchenko is in the lineup and 1-9-0 without. It’s not solely him, but I am confident saying that if he’s healthy over the past 10 games, that is not their record.
Can Gavin McKenna add value? ❌✅
In limited minutes, McKenna has quietly gathered points, and shown the offensive flair that saw him get drafted first overall – the kid can see the ice and make plays.
But he’s 18, only 160 pounds and the five-on-five learning curve has been real. You’d like to see him given more rope when the team’s behind in games (as it almost exclusively has been for weeks) but, frustratingly, it doesn’t seem to use him anymore in those spots.
The talent flashes are breathtaking, and he’s coming along with taking care of the puck, but, like in college, it’ll take some time to work it out.
Can Easton Cowan take a step? ✅
A Bright spot. Cowan’s a legit top-six, even top-line, left winger. He’s a puck hound and a competitor with offensive sense who plays winning hockey.
Can Anthony Stolarz stay healthy and provide value?✅
I’m sure the Leafs hope the early-season game management helped because he can expect to see more action in the weeks ahead. Among goalies who’ve played over 500 minutes this season, a dozen guys have a better save percentage.
So it’s not Vezina-level or anything, but it’s a massive step up from Bobrovsky’s start to the year.
What’s next?
And so with all that said, the next question is, “Is there any reason to believe things will change going forward this season?”
I think the pretty easy answer is, “yes.”
That’s not to say Toronto’s going to suddenly do the inverse of what it’s done here and peel off seven straight wins, but the team’s got a PDO (shooting percentage and save percentage combined) that’s in the bottom-third of the league and that tends to come around when you’ve got the talent the Leafs do.
The Marchenko injury stripped them of play-driving and offence, and he’ll return at some point. It stands to good reason to believe that the management wants to find ways to improve the team, as well.
So, yes, the Leafs should get better, and won’t finish in the league’s bottom five, were they currently sit with a .391 points percentage.
With that said, “better than awful” wasn’t the goal coming into this season as not enough questions from the off-season can be answered in the affirmative. The team’s defence and goaltending got old, and it’s handcuffed when it comes to making significant moves with limited assets and cap space.
Unless the Leafs find Michael Jordan’s secret stuff from Space Jam, they’re in a bad way, and in for a rough ride that’s starting well before American Thanksgiving.






