What will it take for fans to be comfortable returning to NHL arenas?

Fans cheers during the third period of Game 4 of an NHL hockey second-round playoff series between the Carolina Hurricanes and the New York Islanders in Raleigh, N.C., Friday, May 3, 2019. (Gerry Broome/AP)

A question worth asking hockey fans: Without a vaccine, just how comfortable would you be returning to an NHL rink to watch a hockey game right now?

How many people would you cap attendance at, and how far would those people need to sit away from you, to give you sufficient ease to again spend your hard-earned dollars attending NHL action in person? (I guess the additional question here would be “where would daily case counts have to get to?" if that would play into your decision.)

I can’t move past how much I’d love to be sitting in the stands with a hot dog and a big ol’ root beer watching a game right now, yet how utterly ruined it would be were there anyone yelling “SHOOOOOOT” within a hundred feet of me. But of course, that’s just me, and the goal here today is to take the general temperature of hockey fans, a metaphor so fitting I’m genuinely surprised that it came from my own brain.

As science has come to better understand the transmission of COVID-19, there’ve been wins and losses for teams that would like fans to return. A win would be that while the virus can spread through shared high-contact areas, that type of spread is comparably minimal. But aerosol droplets, which abound in plenty when you’re chatting and say, cheering — those are a pretty big problem.

For a more updated look at the likelihood of spread, this article with visualizations is wildly helpful. In a nutshell, you don’t want to be in an enclosed area with anyone for too long unless there’s good ventilation. Arenas are huge open spaces (that can dial up ventilation), which seems like a big plus, but they’re still closed indoor spaces, hence the question here: What sort of spaces and considerations would YOU require to go back?

While the answer to the above is subjective, the rest of the below questions (that have been randomly rattling around in my brain) can be dialled in a little better:

Will we have a play-in round before playoffs again?

I just can’t imagine that with all that’s gone on, in a shortened season, in a sport that already sees random strings of wins and losses based on injuries, variance and otherwise, that the league is going to shut the season down after 50-some games and tell the 17th-best team to go home. They want more meaningful games and more fanbases invested longer, particularly at a time of year when it seems likely fans could fill the stands.

So yes, I would wager there will an “expanded playoffs” again next year with a play-in round that looks something like 7-seed vs. 10-seed and 8 vs. 9 in best-of-threes. Best-of-fives might seem a bit excessive given teams aren’t coming out of a dead stop like they were last time.

I’m gonna hedge this by saying I think some higher-ups in the NHL office don’t like the play-in games, but in the end the money wins out. I think the games happen.

Who loses most if the season is shortened?

Well, there’s the obvious: fans lose, we know that. We lost when the 2019–20 season got paused and again when this season got delayed, and will lose yet again when this shortened campaign ends.

The players lose money, of course, and on a less material level, career records take a hit. The hype about Alex Ovechkin catching Gretzky in all-time goals was strong, and he probably needed a tailwind to actually do it. This little hiccup here might derail his hopes entirely.

Owners take a huge hit here, particularly with every game that’s played without proper gate revenue. Individual teams lose the chance to jell and find themselves over a long season, and good teams like the Tampa Bay Lightning lose momentum. The networks lose live sports, those covering sports take a blow, and — look, it’s all pretty bad, but it is what it is, and we’re all in this together.

I guess it’s impossible to quantify who’s losing MOST, and the only conclusion that can be drawn is we all need proper hockey back ASAP.

What would the NHL’s goals be with this next season?

I think they’re three-fold: bring in as much revenue as possible; try to appease (and further appeal to) NBC; and get back on track for 2021–22.

The revenue thing sounds obvious, but I don’t think it’s the same as in the NBA. There, they seem a little more willing to take some financial hit early (they’re likely back Dec. 22nd) to play more games and get things back to normal (schedule-wise and beyond) as soon as possible.

With the NHL, on the other hand, it seems more important they bring in real dollars (and don’t spend any putting on games in front of nobody) to keep everything afloat as they move towards brighter days.

We’ve heard rumours that they want to be done by the Olympics, as NBC also has the rights for that, so the season would likely have a hard end-point next July. Given they’ll be renegotiating with NBC going into next season, you could see them trying to keep everyone happy there.

And of course, the league needs to get back to being a winter sport. It’s mid-November, and once this election coverage dies down, boy, there’ll be a lot of quiet nights in the depths of winter to come.

And finally:

Who’s going to win the 2020-21 Stanley Cup?

The only teams that I thought could give Tampa a run last season from the West were Colorado and Vegas, and Vegas’s showing against Dallas made me a little skeptical about their ability to score. Colorado was crushed by injuries in the playoffs and still was a breath from making the final, and this off-season they got better.

There’s just no way that Tampa isn’t a little worse than last season, given their cap situation.

And so, while I’m no Nate Silver (though that’s a dubious distinction at the moment), I’ll go ahead and put myself down on Nov. 6 as forecasting the Avs as 2021 Stanley Cup Champions.

When submitting content, please abide by our  submission guidelines, and avoid posting profanity, personal attacks or harassment. Should you violate our submissions guidelines, we reserve the right to remove your comments and block your account. Sportsnet reserves the right to close a story’s comment section at any time.