Blue Jays’ Game 1 loss hinges on lifeless offence, not pitching moves

Blake Snell struck out nine Blue Jays batters as the Rays took Game 1 with a 3-1 win.

TORONTO – Keep debating the merits of the Toronto Blue Jays’ pitching strategy all you like, but for Game 1, at least, it worked. Matt Shoemaker and Robbie Ray combined for six innings of relatively uneventful one-run ball, and if ace Hyun-Jin Ryu pitches similarly with his team’s season on the line Wednesday everyone will be thrilled.

Either way, the unorthodox approach to the wild-card series opener against the Tampa Bay Rays isn’t what cost them in their first post-season game since 2016, and it won’t be what ultimately decides things when all is said and done.

The real issue coming out of Tuesday’s 3-1 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays is the way lefty Blake Snell overpowered the Blue Jays with a fastball that averaged 95.3 m.p.h., and mixed in his secondary weapons to induce 15 swings out of the zone that led to a foul ball or a miss.

Relievers Diego Castillo (three), Nick Anderson (four) and Pete Fairbanks (three) also got the Blue Jays to chase, and the departure from the more-disciplined approach is something they’ll need to address before stepping in against Tyler Glasnow with win-or-go-home stakes.

“We did chase a lot,” lamented manager Charlie Montoyo. “We struck out nine times against Snell. But I do know that when he’s on, that’s what hitters usually do and I could tell he was on. I’m not defending our hitters — yeah, you want them to do better. But Snell was on and I could tell that from the beginning. There was no room for error here.”

The successful pairing of Shoemaker and Ray — a lightning bolt that charged Blue Jays discourse — provided the offence with every opportunity.

Shoemaker, pitching for the first time since returning from the injured list with three strong innings against the New York Yankees on Sept. 21, shoved right out of the gate, and was so in control that he needed only 35 pitches to skip through three innings on two weak hits.

He initially appeared upset when pitching coach Pete Walker and Montoyo told him he was done, but calmed, reminded of the club’s predetermined plan. The Blue Jays had only intended to let him go through the Rays order once — it might have been two innings if he had been less efficient — although Shoemaker hoped that his work would sway them to let him pitch on.

“To be completely honest, I didn’t think it was going to be after the third,” he said. “The good thing is before the start, going into it, we talked about the potential game-plans, I understood what was going on, and just moving into, hey, maybe reading the flow of the game, maybe I’ll go four, five, who knows? And Robbie comes in and does his thing for three, four, five. So at first I was maybe surprised to come out. But it is what it is. I don’t make those decisions. Robbie came in and pitched really well.”

Not immediately.

Livestream Toronto Blue Jays games all season with Sportsnet NOW. Plus, watch marquee MLB matchups, the post-season and World Series.

The first batter Ray faced, Randy Arozarena, ripped a leadoff triple, and after a Nate Lowe strikeout, he ripped off a full-count slider to Willy Adames for Ball 4 that just barely squirted through catcher Danny Jansen’s legs as he slid over to block it.

The ball rolled away just far enough for Arozarena to scamper home for a 1-0 lead. Ray settled from there with two shutout innings.

“It worked out just like we mapped it out,” said Montoyo. “In the sixth inning when it was only 1-0, I said, man, we’ve got a chance because that’s how we mapped it out, and they both did a great job. We didn’t hit today.”

The lack of offence became more acute in the seventh, when Joey Wendle worked a one-out walk off A.J. Cole, who proceeded to serve up a middle-middle cutter that Manuel Margot lined over the wall in left.

The Rays were creative with their pitching deployment, too, pulling Snell with two outs in the sixth despite allowing only one hit and a walk while striking out nine on 82 pitches. Snell generated 18 swinging strikes in total, getting multiple misses on each of his curveball (eight), changeup (three) and slider (two).

“What he does best is get a lot of chase,” said Cavan Biggio. “I think what he did a good job of was getting ahead, and getting to two strikes early, kind of what a couple of days ago what John Means did to us, keeping us off-balance.”

Castillo stranded Alejandro Kirk’s leadoff single in the sixth but put on a pair with one out in the seventh, which is when the Rays turned to Anderson, who got Teoscar Hernandez and pinch-hitter Joe Panik to end the threat.

The Jays finally broke through in the eighth, as pinch-hitter Rowdy Tellez — a surprise addition to the post-season roster — singled, Biggio doubled and Bo Bichette brought Tellez home with a sacrifice fly. Randal Grichuk followed with a liner to Adames at short, placed well by the Rays, for the final out.

Fairbanks triple-digit fastballed his way around a Lourdes Gurriel Jr., double in the ninth to close things out in the first post-season game for seven of the nine players in the Blue Jays batting order.

“I didn’t really see a huge difference,” Biggio said of the post-season experience. “Once I step inside the lines, I treat every game and every pitch like it could be my last. The absence of fans probably helped a little bit with that, honestly, but we all know the importance of this game and this series and the biggest thing is to slow it down.”

The decision to go with the Shoemaker/Ray tandem over Ryu in Game 1 is among the most polarizing in recent Blue Jays playoff history. An interesting comparable came in Game 4 of the 2015 AL Division Series, when then manager John Gibbons pulled R.A. Dickey with two out in the fifth and a 7-1 lead over the Texas Rangers, bringing in David Price in a call that locked in Marcus Stroman as the starter in the decisive fifth game.

While few understood that call, before that game Gibbons watched the Kansas City Royals rally from a 6-2 deficit to stave off elimination with a 9-6 win over the Houston Astros, and was determined to not give the Rangers any life.

This time, the Blue Jays were dealing with vastly different circumstances, facing an opponent eight games better than them in the standings and deeper on a number of levels. That prompted the club to holistically examine how to attack a three-game series — a first for Major League Baseball — and they determined that “in this scenario, Game 1 seemed much less significant than in a traditional scenario, significantly different,” said GM Ross Atkins.

“We viewed the advantage (in) being able to put our most consistent piece in the middle of those potentially 27-plus innings, as we thought through our strategy,” he added, “with the added benefit of getting an extra day rest for Hyun-Jin Ryu, an extra day of rest for Taijuan Walker, and then giving our bullpen the chance to be its strongest on Game 1 and Game 3.”

That bucks conventional thinking, fuelling the debate. Since the wild-card era began in 1995, teams that win Game 1 are 126-49 in the series, regardless of round or length, which is why Ryu seemed like an automatic, if he didn’t physically need an extra day.

The Blue Jays and Ryu both said that wasn’t the case, but part of their calculations was that an inability to bring the Game 1 starter back again in a best-of-three — as opposed to making two starts in a longer series — minimized some of the incentive. Another factor was that pitching in Game 2 would still allow Ryu to pitch the opener of the division series, should they get that far.

Also, the Blue Jays felt that if the Rays stacked their lineup with left-handed bats against Shoemaker, putting in Ray would force them to either surrender platoon advantage against the lefty, or the righty relievers to follow him later.

Cleverly, Rays manager Kevin Cash countered that by stacking only two left-handed batters — Yoshi Tsutsugo and Brandon Lowe — in the first two spots of the order, alternating righties and lefties from there. They only made one move during Ray’s three innings — hitting Hunter Renfroe for Tsutsugo in the fifth.

These types of machinations are part of why the Blue Jays hired Montoyo, after first pursuing his staff-mate on the Rays, Rocco Baldelli, who ended up opting for the Minnesota Twins’ managerial opening.

Montoyo brought with him a window into the Rays’ highly respected methodology, so perhaps it shouldn’t be surprising that the Blue Jays sought to emulate it.

“That’s one thing I got in every interview I did, it was about the opener and the Rays and the things that they did,” said Montoyo. “So it wasn’t only Ross, it was also with the other teams that interviewed with because credit to the Rays, they’re so creative and what they do is different. At first it looks like, ‘What are they doing?’ But they’re not afraid to take a chance. And that’s what we’re doing here. We’re trying to be creative playing one of the best teams in baseball. That’s why we’re doing what we’re doing.”

In terms of giving themselves a chance, the tandem start worked, getting them to the bullpen with the game under control. But Snell’s performance was an element they couldn’t script, and that’s why the Blue Jays will be playing for their season in Game 2.

When submitting content, please abide by our submission guidelines, and avoid posting profanity, personal attacks or harassment. Should you violate our submissions guidelines, we reserve the right to remove your comments and block your account. Sportsnet reserves the right to close a story’s comment section at any time.