While the Toronto Blue Jays are linked to players at the top of the free-agent market, the team’s off-season won’t solely consist of shopping for big-ticket additions.
Putting together a successful roster revamp involves finding helpful role players who plug holes and step up when injuries strike. Several players who fit that description are already available in free agency, but some new possibilities emerged on Friday with the non-tender deadline. Teams around the majors cut loose arbitration-eligible players they didn’t intend to roster in 2027, and a few guys who might fit with the Blue Jays became available.
Below are some players worth watching who just hit the market:
Trevor Larnach
Age: 29
Position: OF/DH
2026 Stats: .269/.352/.436 in 433 PA with 15 HR for a 123 wRC+ and 2.1 fWAR
Possible Appeal: The Blue Jays aren’t hurting for left-handed outfielders, or players who project to command DH at-bats. In a world where Anthony Santander and Addison Barger are both on the roster whenever 2027 opens, there probably isn’t room for Larnach.
At the same time, that doesn’t feel like a given, and Larnach is a safe bet to mash right-handed pitching. A team that struggled so badly to score in 2026 should consider a hitter who’s slashed .266/.345/.440 against righties in 1,204 plate appearances over the last three years — good for a 121 wRC+. Larnach is also coming off career-best wRC+ (123) and fWAR (2.2) marks, cutting his strikeouts while producing an ISO (.167) above his career average (.163).

Larnach is a legitimate Plan A in a platoon corner outfield spot or as a top option as a DH against right-handed pitching. He’s a high-floor, relatively low-ceiling option for that role, but if more significant lineup upgrades came elsewhere — like at second base — he could bring some certainty to a group of hitters that currently lacks it. Larnach isn’t a player the team would structure its top off-season plans around. There’s a reason the Minnesota Twins non-tendered him when his arbitration salary was projected to be $6.3 million. Still, if a bigger roster shuffle dislodged one of Santander or Barger, Larnach would become intriguing.
The biggest downside in his relatively safe profile might be the off-season wrist surgery he underwent, but he’ll reportedly be ready for a full hitting program in January.
JP Sears
Age: 30
Position: SP/RP
2026 Stats: 6.98 K/9, 3.03 BB/9, and 32.2 HR/9 in 33.2 IP with a 4.68 ERA and 5.15 xERA
Possible Appeal: Sears is coming off a rough 2026 season that saw him make 20 starts in triple-A, but there are a couple of reasons he might be of interest to the Blue Jays.
The first is that he has a history of durability. Between 2023 and 2025, he made at least 31 starts each season, and last year’s dip (26) was due to his yo-yoing between the minors and majors instead of injury. The Blue Jays have always prized durable arms, and as a swingman or depth starter, he’d be a strong bet to be available even if he didn’t excel on a per-inning basis. Having a player like Sears in-house would make mid-season desperation adds — like Patrick Corbin in 2026 — less likely.
Sears is also a southpaw, and the Blue Jays are low on major-league lefties. If the season began today, the club wouldn’t have a left-hander in the rotation, and the bullpen is in desperate need of one to complement the overused Mason Fluharty. Sears has made just eight major-league relief appearances in his career, but his success as a back-of-the-rotation starter bodes well for his chances of thriving in the pen. It’s possible a little more fastball velocity and a tighter repertoire could even unlock a higher performance level. Toronto lacks a true low-leverage long-man, as their best candidate for multi-inning stints (Spencer Miles) is overqualified to mop up innings. Sears could function as a long-relief option/occasional situational lefty who can be stretched out for starts if injuries demand it.
That wide scope of utility shouldn’t be confused with the likelihood of shutdown results, but Sears could be a floor-raiser for the Blue Jays.
James Karinchak
Age: 31
Position: RP
2026 Stats: 7.45 K/9, 4.66 BB/9, and 0.93 HR/9 in 9.2 IP with a 1.83 ERA and 2.99 xERA
Possible Appeal: Karinchak is the type of reliever who’d have to compete for a bullpen job on a minor-league contract, but understood in that context, he’s a legitimately interesting talent.
Between 2020 and 2023, the right-hander was one of the most reliable bat-missers in baseball with a 36.3 per cent strikeout rate that ranked ninth among the 489 pitchers with at least 100 innings pitched in that span. That was a while back, but after his 2024 was erased by a shoulder issue and he couldn’t recapture his peak velocity in 2025, spending the season in triple-A, 2026 was more encouraging.
Karinchak still pitched most of last season at triple-A, but his velocity rebounded, and his strikeout rate there (35.8 per cent) was impressive. He didn’t miss as many bats in his brief MLB cameo, but his fastball averaged 95.0 m.p.h., a tiny uptick from his last full season in the majors back in 2023 (94.8 m.p.h.). The 31-year-old’s arm angle has flattened a bit since his best seasons, and his curveball movement isn’t quite the same, but he has far more potential than most dart-throw options.
Outside of Louis Varland, Tyler Rogers, Braydon Fisher and Fluharty, the Blue Jays don’t have many relievers locked into roster spots, and Karinchak could compete for low-leverage work.
Fernando Cruz
Age: 36
Position: RP
2026 Stats: 11.03 K/9, 5.27 BB/9, and 1.15 HR/9 in 54.2 IP with a 3.30 ERA and 3.13 xERA
Possible Appeal: From a pure track-record standpoint, there isn’t reason to doubt Cruz’s ability to make a positive impact in the Blue Jays bullpen. Over the last two seasons, he’s provided 102.2 innings of 3.33 ERA ball, striking out an impressive 139 hitters in the process. He is a stylistically extreme pitcher who ranked in the 99th percentile in whiff rate and hard-hit rate in 2026, but below the fifth percentile in walk rate and groundball percentage. He doesn’t have big-time velocity (93.2 m.p.h. average fastball), but his splitter is one of the nastiest pitches in the game, earning a whiff rate above 50 per cent in each of his five MLB seasons.
Cruz is unusual, but his performance alone wouldn’t make him a non-tender candidate. His issue is health, as he finished 2026 on the IL with a shoulder issue. That’s daunting, particularly for a pitcher his age, but he’ll reportedly be ready for the beginning of 2027 with no surgery required.
The New York Yankees clearly lacked confidence in his recovery, or they wouldn’t have non-tendered him, and any pursuit of Cruz would require a complete understanding of his physical state. New York’s assessment that he’s not worthy of a major-league contract at this time may be correct, but the Yankees’ front office is far from infallible. Not many 36-year-olds coming off notable injuries can reasonably be classified as “high-upside”, but that label might just fit Cruz.






